There are many recipes online where you can make Halloween goodies that look like fingers. In fact, several years ago I posted a recipe from Martha Stewart for "Ladies Fingers and Mens Toes". And while I adore Martha Stewart, I can't live on four hours of sleep like she can and I don't always have time to make edible Halloween appendages.
So please forgive me when I cheat and buy these Shortbread Fingers from Williams Sonoma. Made from all natural ingredients, these shortbread cookies are hand rolled and decorated. Each 3 inch finger is individually wrapped.
$19.95 for a set of 10 (8 ounce total)
You can find them here.